Talk Back! How are we feeling about the state of the Giants roster?

Did general manager Dave Gettleman give the coaching staff enough talent to work with? Tell us in the comments below.Danielle Parhizkaran/NorthJersey.com via USA TODAY NETWORK

The training camp roster is set. But what concerns do you have about this team head of training camp?

Welcome to Talk Back!

Every Monday I'll post a new question. To participate, all you need to do is sign up for a FREE account on this site (it talks less than a minute, and did I mention it's FREE?), log into your account and post to the comments below.

So that we can build the community and keep everything orderly, please make sure you're posting your responses in the comments (where you have finite space) rather than on Twitter. (And yes, I will be checking the responses posted and chiming in!)

Here is this week's question:

With the Giants spring practices wrapped up, how are you feeling about this team?

Talk Back!

Comments (24)
No. 1-10
ejmaxon
ejmaxon

Hey Patricia, how do you feel about Daniel Jones' spring/early summer? Has he surprised you (good or bad) in any way? Has his performance changed your outlook on his future at all?

Same questions for Dexter Lawrence. I feel like I haven't read/heard much about him in his early Giants career.

Jonesin4QB
Jonesin4QB

After my initial knee jerk reaction of doom and gloom when Gettleman passed on Allen at 6, I'm feeling optimistic. I can't wait to see them in full gear and practicing at full speed.

HoogieCoogieMan
HoogieCoogieMan

The offense this year is solid, finally with some OL. The defense is still a question. Three out of four DB are vets, lots of youth afterwards, great. Front 7, can they generate a pass rush, stop the run, to be determined. Overall, think this year's team is better than last year. A big part is the Hope that the play calling adapts to the personnel. Feel good about the team, looking for 8-8 or slightly better. DG has a tough job rebuilding after the JR disaster.

EMPIREPRMAN
EMPIREPRMAN

The secondary looks way better. Lots of depth there. OL is improved, but I am concerned about the depth. Can Evan Engram stay healthy? His speed is very much needed. Who will emerge as the primary pass rushers? Definitely improvements, but still lots of questions.

BigBlueGmen1986
BigBlueGmen1986

Guys running around in shorts means nothing. It appears the O and D are fairly equal. Whether the talent is poor mediocre or actually good remains to be seen. We’ll just have to wait until September



Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
1
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
New Comment
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
New Comment
1
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
New Comment
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
New Comment
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
New Comment
Patricia Traina
EditorPatricia Traina
New Comment